- Physical Review Journals
All JournalsPhysics Magazine
Access Provided by Xinjiang University

Reviews of Modern Physics

Export citation

Export citation

Choose format for download:

Download Citation
  • Access by Xinjiang University

How the first neutral-current experiments ended

Peter Galison

Peter Galison

  • Lyman Laboratory of Physics, Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02138

PDF

Rev. Mod. Phys. 55, 477 – Published 1 April, 1983

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/RevModPhys.55.477

Abstract

At the beginning of the 1970s there seemed little reason to believe that strangeness-conserving neutral currents existed: theoreticians had no pressing need for them and several experiments suggested that they were suppressed if they were present at all. Indeed the two remarkable neutrino experiments that eventually led to their discovery were designed and built for very different purposes, including the search for the vector boson and the investigation of the parton model. In retrospect we know that certain gauge theories (notably the Weinberg-Salam model) predicted that neutral currents exist. But until 't Hooft and Veltman proved that such theories were renormalizable, little effort was made to test the new theories. After the proof the two experimental groups began to reorient their goals to settle an increasingly central issue of physics. Do neutral currents exist? We ask here: What kind of evidence and arguments persuaded the participants that they had before them a real effect and not an artifact of the apparatus? What eventually convinced them that their experiment was over? An answer to these questions requires an examination of the organization of the experiments, the nature of the apparatus, and the previous work of the experimentalists. Finally, some general observations are made about the recent evolution of experimental physics.

View figure in article

References (128)

  1. Abers, E. S., and B. W. Lee, 1973, Phys. Rep. 9, 1
  2. Allard, J. F., B. Aubert, C. Baglin, L. Behr, P. Beilliere, A. Bezaguet, V. Brisson, L. Carlino, L. M. Chounet, R. Florent, R. Hecart, J. Hennesy, F. Jacquet, L. Jauneau, A. Lagarrigue, G. Lemesle, A. Lloret, J. P. Lowys, D. Morelet, P. Musset, V. Nguyen-Khac, M. Ohayon, A. Orkin-Lecourtois, C. Pascaud, P. Petiau, P. Queru, P. Rançon, M. Reposeur, A. Rousset, J. Six, and J. J. Veillet, 1964, Bubble-Chamber Proposal, Ecole Polytechnique, Summer 1964
  3. Anonymous, 1973, referee reports for Phys. Rev. Lett., October
  4. Aubert, B., 1970, letter to D. H. Perkins, 27 February
  5. Aubert, B., 1973, letter to Neutrino Collaboration at NAL, 16 October
  6. Aubert, B., et al., 1970, amended draft to the Gargamelle Proposal, 25 February
  7. Aubert, B., et al., 1974a (see footnote 1), Phys. Rev. Lett. 32, 1454
  8. Aubert, B., A. Benvenuti, D. Cline, W. T. Ford, R. Imaly, J. Y. Ling, A. K. Mann, F. Messing, J. Pilcher, D. D. Reeder, C. Rubbia, R. Stefanski, and L. Sulak, 1974b, Phys. Rev. Lett. 32, 1457
  9. Aubert, B., F. Ling, and R. Imlay, 1973, technical memorandum, 18 December
  10. Baltay, C., U. Camerini, W. Fry, P. Musset, B. Osculati, and A. Pullia, 1972a, CERN-TCL, technical memorandum, 14 July
  11. Baltay, C., U. Camerini, W. Fry, P. Musset, B. Osculati, and A. Pullia, 1972b, CERN-TCL, technical memorandum, 14 July
  12. Baltay, C., 1979, in Proceedings of the 19th International Conference on High Energy Physics, Tokyo, August 23-30, 1978, edited by S. Homma, M. Kawaguchi, and H. Miyazawa (Physical Society of Japan, Tokyo), p. 882
  13. Barish, B. C., 1974, in Proceedings of the XVII International Conference on High Energy Physics, London, July, 1974, edited by J. R. Smith (Science Research Council, Rutherford Laboratory, Chilton), p. IV-III
  14. Beier, E. W., D. Cline, A. K. Mann, J. Pilcher, D. D. Reeder, and C. Rubbia, 1970, draft HWPF proposal
  15. Beier, E., D. A. Buchholz, A. K. Mann, and S. H. Parker, 1972, Phys. Rev. Lett. 29, 678
  16. Bell, J. S., J. Løvseth, and M. Veltman, 1963, in Proceedings of the Sienna International Conference on Elementary Particles 30 September—5 October, 1963, edited by G. Bernardini and G. Puppi (Societá Italiana di Fisica, Bologna), Vol. 1, p. 584
  17. Benvenuti, A., D. Cline, R. L. Imlay, W. Ford, A. K. Mann, J. E. Pilcher, D. D. Reeder, C. Rubbia, and L. R. Sulak, 1972, letter to R. R. Wilson, 14 March
  18. Benvenuti, A., D. Cheng, D. Cline, W. T. Ford, R. Imlay, T. Y. Ling, A. K. Mann, F. Messing, J. Pilcher, D. D. Reeders, C. Rubbia, and L. Sulak, 1973, Phys. Rev. Lett. 30, 1084
  19. Benvenuti, A., et al., 1974a, 1974b (see footnote 1), Phys. Rev. Lett. 32, 800
  20. Bernardini, G., 1966 in Proceedings of the International School of Physics "Enrico Fermi" Course XXXII (Academic, New York), p. 1
  21. Bingham, H. H., et al., in Proceedings of the Sienna International Conference on Elementary Particles 30 September—5 October, 1963, edited by G. Bernardini and G. Puppi (Societá Italian di Fisica, Bologna), Vol. 1, p. 555
  22. Bjorken, J. D., and E. A. Paschos, 1969, Phys. Rev. 185, 1975
  23. Block, M. M., H. Burmeister, D. C. Cundy, B. Eiben, C. Franzinetti, J. Keren, R. Møllerud, G. Myatt, M. Nikolic, A. Orkin-Lecourtois, M. Paty, D. H. Perkins, C. A. Ramm, K. Schultze, H. Sletten, K. Soop, R. Stump, W. Venus, and H. Yoshiki, 1964, Phys. Lett. 12, 281
  24. Breidenbach, M., J. I. Friedman, H. W. Kendall, E. D. Bloom, D. H. Coward, H. DeStaebler, J. Drees, L. W. Mo, and R. E. Taylor, 1969, Phys. Rev. Lett. 23, 935
  25. Camerini, U., D. Cline, W. F. Fry, and W. M. Powell, 1964, Phys. Rev. Lett. 13, 318
  26. Camerini, U., D. Ljung, M. Sheaff, and D. Cline, 1969, Phys. Rev. Lett. 23, 326
  27. Christenson, J. H., J. W. Cronin, V. L. Fitch, and R. Turlay, 1964, Phys. Rev. Lett. 13, 138
  28. Cline, D., 1967, "Experimental Search for Weak Neutral Currents." Preprinted from the school held in Heceg Novi, Yugoslavia
  29. Cline, D., 1973a, Wisconsin, technical memorandum, 1 October
  30. Cline, D., 1973b, Wisconsin, technical memorandum, 11 October
  31. Cline, D., 1973c, Wisconsin, technical memorandum, 16 October
  32. Cline, D., 1973d, Wisconsin, technical memorandum, 13 December with xeroxed transparencies of 6 December FNAL talk
  33. Cline, D., 1979, Preface to Unification of Elementary Forces and Gauge Theories: Proceedings Ben Lee Memorial International Conference on Parity Nonconservation, Weak Neutral Currents, and Gauge Theories, FNAL Oct. 20-22, 1977, edited by D. B. Cline and F. E. Mills (Harwood Academic, London), p. ix
  34. Cline, D., 1981, interview, 14 January
  35. Cline, D., and W. F. Fry, 1977, Annu. Rev. Nucl. Sci. 27, 209
  36. Cline, D., and A. K. Mann, 1969, "Preliminary Version of a Proposal for Neutrino Scattering Experiments at NAL," draft NAL proposal, 18 December
  37. Cline, D., A. K. Mann, and C. Rubbia, 1970, Phys. Rev. Lett. 25, 1309
  38. Commins, E. D., 1973, Weak Interactions (McGraw-Hill, New York)
  39. Cronin, J. W., 1981, Rev. Mod. Phys. 53, 373
  40. Cundy, D. C., 1964, in XII International Conference on High Energy Physics, Dubna, 5—15 August, 1964 (Atomizdat, Moscow), p. 7
  41. Cundy, D. C., 1973, in CERN-TCL, minutes 21 March, 26 March
  42. Cundy, D. C., 1974, in Proceedings of the XVII International Conference on High Energy Physics, London, July, 1974, edited by J. R. Smith (Science Research Council, Rutherford Laboratory, Chilton), p. IV-131
  43. Cundy, D. C., 1980, interview, 27 November
  44. Cundy, D. C., and C. Baltay, 1972, CERN-TCL, technical memorandum, 11 July
  45. Cundy, D. C., G. Myatt, F. A. Nezrick, J. B. M. Pattison, D. H. Perkins, C. A. Ramm, W. Venus, and H. W. Wachsmuth, 1970, Phys. Lett. B 31, 478
  46. Danby, G., J-M. Gaillard, K. Goulianos, L. M. Lederman, N. Mistry, M. Schwartz, and J. Steinberger, 1962, Phys. Rev. Lett. 9, 36
  47. Faissner, H., 1973a, letter to A. Lagarrigue, 11 January
  48. Faissner, H., 1973b, letter to W. Jentschke, 9 February
  49. Faissner, H., 1979, in New Phemonea in Lepton-Hadron Physics, edited by D. Fries and J. Wess (Plenum, New York)
  50. Faissner, H., 1981, letter to author, 7 December
  51. Feinberg, G., 1964, in Brandeis Summer Institute in Theoretical Physics. Lectures on Astrophysics and Weak Interactions, (Colony Offset, Boston), p. 278
  52. Fermi, E., 1934, Z. Phys. 88, 161
  53. Feynman, R., 1969, in High Energy Collisions, Third International Conference, State University of New York, Stony Brook, September 5 and 6, 1969, edited by C. N. Yang, J. A. Cole, M. Good, R. Hwa, and J. Lee-Franzini (Gordon and Breach, New York), p. 237
  54. Feynman, R. P., 1974, in Neutrinos-1974 (Philadelphia) AIP Conference Proceedings No. 22, Particles and Fields Subseries No. 9, edited by C. Baltay (American Institute of Physics, New York), p. 299
  55. Fiorini, E., 1973, letter to Musset, 11 July
  56. Fitch, V. L., 1981, Rev. Mod. Phys. 53, 367
  57. Ford, W. T., and A. K. Mann, 1973, Pennsylvania, technical memorandum, 28 November
  58. Frauenfelder, H., and E. Henley, 1974, Subatomic Physics (Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs)
  59. Fry, W., and D. Haidt, 1973, CERN-TCL, technical memorandum, 22 May
  60. Fry, W. F., and D. Haidt, 1975, CERN yellow report 75-1
  61. Glashow, S. L., 1980, Rev. Mod. Phys. 52, 539
  62. Glashow, S. L., and H. Georgi, 1972, Phys. Rev. Lett. 28, 1494
  63. Glashow S. L., J. Illiopoulos, and L. Maiani, 1970, Phys. Rev. D 2, 1285
  64. Gurr, H. S., F. Reines, and H. W. Sobel, 1972, Phys. Rev. Lett. 28, 1406
  65. Hasert, F. J., et al., 1973a, Phys. Lett. B 46, 121
  66. Hasert, F. J., et al., 1973b (see footnote 1) Phys. Lett. B 46, 138
  67. Hasert, F. J., et al., 1974 (see footnote 1) Nucl. Phys. B 73, 1
  68. Imlay, R., 1973a, Wisconsin, technical memorandum, 29 November
  69. Imlay, R., 1973b, Wisconsin, technical memorandum, 29 November
  70. Kabir, P. K., 1963, in The Development of Weak Interaction Theory, edited by P. K. Kabir (Gordon and Breach, New York)
  71. Kim, J. E., P. Langacker, M. Levine, and H. H. Williams, 1981, Rev. Mod. Phys. 53, 211
  72. Lagarrigue, A., 1972, letter to W. Jentschke, 12 April
  73. Lagarrigue, A., 1973a, letter to H. Faissner, 16 January
  74. Lagarrigue, A., 1973b, letter to C. Rubbia, 19 July
  75. Lagarrigue, A., P. Musset, and A. Rousset, 1964, "Projet de Chambre á Liquides Lourds de 17m3," Draft Project Proposal for Bubble Chamber, Ecole Polytechnique, February
  76. Lee, B. W., 1972a, Phys. Lett. B 40, 420
  77. Lee, B. W., 1972b, in XVI International Conference on High Energy Physics (NAL, Batavia) Vol. 4, p. 249
  78. Lee, W., 1972, Phys. Lett. B 40, 423
  79. Lee, W., 1974, in Proceedings of the XVII International Conference on High Energy Physics, London, July 1974, edited by J. R. Smith (Science Research Council, Rutherford Laboratory, Chilton), p. IV-127
  80. Lee, T. D., and C. N. Yang, 1960a, Phys. Rev. Lett. 4, 307
  81. Lee, T. D., and C. N. Yang, 1960b, Phys. Rev. 119, 1410
  82. Mann, A. K., 1969, 1969 Summer Study, Volume 4 Particle Beams (NAL, Batavia), p. 201
  83. Mann, A. K., 1974, Pennsylvania, technical memorandum, with spark-chamber photographs, 26 January
  84. Mann, A. K., 1977, Unification of Elementary Forces and Gauge Theories (Harwood Academic, London), p. 20
  85. Mann, A. K., 1980, interview, 29 September
  86. Marshak, R. E., Riazuddin, and C. P. Ryan, 1969, Theory of Weak Interactions in Particle Physics (Wiley-Interscience, New York)
  87. Musset, P., 1972, transparencies from presentation to American Physical Society Meeting, New York, January 1973
  88. Musset, P., 1973a, CERN-TCL, technical memorandum, 19 March
  89. Musset, P., 1973b, CERN-TCL, technical memorandum, 26 March
  90. Musset, P., 1973c, CERN-TCL, technical memorandum, 17 April
  91. Musset, P., 1973d, in 2nd International Conference on Elementary Particles, Aix-en Provence 6—12 September, J. Phys. (Paris) 34, Supplement to Number 10, Colloque C1, p. C1-45
  92. Musset, P., 1980, interview, 26 November
  93. Musset, P., 1982, letter to author, 2 April
  94. Musset, P., and J. P. Vialle, 1973, CERN-TCL, technical memorandum, 20 November
  95. Myatt, G., 1974, in Proceedings of the 6th International Symposium on Electron and Photon Interactions at High Energies, Physikalisches Institut, University of Bonn, August 27-31, 1973, edited by H. Rollnik and W. Pfeil (North-Holland, Amsterdam), p. 389
  96. Pais, A., and S. B. Treiman, 1972, Phys. Rev. D 6, 2700
  97. Paschos, E. A., and L. Wolfenstein, 1973, Phys. Rev. D 7, 91
  98. Perkins, D. H., 1970, "Draft Gargamelle Proposal," 24 February
  99. Perkins, D. H., 1972a, in Proceedings of the XVI International Conference on High Energy Physics, 6 September-13 September, Volume 4 (NAL, Batavia), p. 189
  100. Perkins, D. H., 1972b, technical memorandum, addressed to Gargamelle collaboration, undated but before 28 April
  101. Perkins, D. H., 1972c, letter to C. Baltay, 28 April (copies to Gargamelle collaboration)
  102. Pullia, A., 1972, in Neutrino '72, Europhysics Conference, Balatonfüred, Hungary, 11-17 June, 1972, edited by A. Frenkel and G. Marx (Omkdk-Technioinform, Budapest), Vol. 1, p. 229
  103. Reeder, D., 1973, "Report of Bonn Conference," Internal Report, 4 September
  104. Rousset, A., 1973a, memorandum to Professor Cresti, CERN-TCL, 19 February
  105. Rousset, A., 1973b, CERN-TCL, 22 May
  106. Rousset, A., 1974, in Neutrinos-1974 (Philadelphia), AIP Conference Proceedings No. 22, Particles and Fields Subseries No. 9, edited by C. Baltay (American Institute of Physics, New York), p. 141
  107. Rousset, A., 1980, interview, 30 November
  108. Rubbia, C., 1973, letter to A. Lagarrigue, 17 July
  109. Rubbia, C., 1980, interview, 3 October
  110. Rubbia, C., and L. Sulak, 1973, "Analysis of Neutrino Events with No Associated Muon," Harvard, technical memorandum, 18 August
  111. Sakurai, J. J., 1974, in Neutrinos-1974, (Philadelphia) AIP Conference Proceedings No. 22, Particles and Fields Subseries No. 9, edited by C. Baltay (American Institute of Physics, New York), p. 57
  112. Salam, A., 1968, in Elementary Particle Physics, edited by N. Svartholm (Almquist and Wiksells, Stockholm), p. 367
  113. Schreiner, P., 1974, in Proceedings of the XVII International Conference on High Energy Physics, London, July 1974, edited by J. R. Smith (Science Research Council, Rutherford Laboratory, Chilton), p. IV-123
  114. Schwartz, M., 1960, Phys. Rev. Lett. 4, 306
  115. Sulak, L. R., 1973, technical memorandum, 17 November
  116. Sulak, L. R., 1980, interview, 8 September
  117. Sullivan, D., D. Koester, D. H. White, and R. Kern, 1980, Scientometrics 2, 309
  118. Taylor, J. C., 1976, Gauge Theories of Weak Interactions (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, England)
  119. t'Hooft, G., 1971a, Nucl. Phys. B 33, 173
  120. t'Hooft, G., 1971b, Phys. Lett. B 37, 195
  121. Vialle, J. P., 1980, interview, 28 November
  122. Vialle, J. P., and D. Blum 1973, Orsay, technical memorandum, 15 May
  123. Wachsmuth, H., 1973, CERN-TCL, 24 May
  124. Weinberg, S., 1967, Phys. Rev. Lett. 19, 1264
  125. Weinberg, S., 1972, Phys Rev. D 5, 1412
  126. Weinberg, S., 1973, in 2nd International Conference on Elementary Particles Aix-en-Provence 6-12 September 1973, J. Phys. (Paris) 34, Supplement to Number 10, Colloque C1, p. C1-45
  127. Weinberg, S., 1980, Rev. Mod. Phys. 52, 515
  128. Young, E. C. M., 1967 CERN yellow report 67-12

Outline

Information

Rev. Mod. Phys. 55, 477– Published 1 April, 1983

    © 1983 American Physical Society

    Sign In to Your Journals Account

    Filter

    Filter

    Article Lookup

    Enter a citation